Rio Tinto and Meridian compete for one more spherical of brinkmanship on the Bluff

Evaluation: It’s ironic that the closest city to Tiwai Level Aluminum is known as Bluff.

Kiwis might have been forgiven for rolling their eyes on the announcement final week that Sulfur’s majority proprietor, Rio Tinto, is now in talks with energy corporations about extending Sulfur’s life past its newest believed shutdown date of late 2024. is having a dialog

Rio Tinto had beforehand threatened to make just one compensation announcement in 2021 and earlier than that in 2013 – first in change for a $30 million authorities hand-out after which sharp worth cuts to its main energy provider, Meridian Vitality. , fees the smelter for electrical energy.

In 2000, in opposition to the backdrop of aluminum costs falling beneath US$2000 (NZ$3170) per tonne, Rio Tinto determined to terminate a contract that may have assured its energy till 2030, at a worth of round $55 per megawatt. – Hour is (5.5). ca kilowatt-hour).

learn extra:
* Aluminum smelter begins talks with energy companies to maintain smelter after 2024
* Meridian units phrases for ’10 to twenty 12 months’ take care of aluminum sulphur
* Negotiations to ‘save’ the aluminum smelter once more might face extra issues

Seemingly unconcerned about whether or not the smelter remained open, it then succeeded in bringing a smelter Meridian all the way down to a worth deemed to be round $35/MWh in its present contract.

Jordan analyst Grant Swanepoel says Meridian’s “gun to the pinnacle” saved about $120 million a 12 months for 4 years.

However this time the sport of brinkmanship will play out in barely completely different circumstances.

Aluminum costs are presently buying and selling at a a lot more healthy US$2500/tonne and Rio Tinto has clearly indicated that it want to preserve the smelter open past the top of 2024, which is not going to be attainable till Till it secures a brand new energy deal.

There’s hypothesis that an settlement is prone to be at a worth of $60 to $80/MWh, with billions of {dollars} probably at stake the place it lands in that band.

A worth on the higher finish of that band would increase the likelihood that Rio Tinto would have been higher off by no means breaking apart its unique energy contract, and as a substitute letting it run till 2030.

However Swanepoel believes such schadenfreude is unlikely, as its personal modeling suggests it might nonetheless be in Meridian’s curiosity to strike a deal at a worth above $62/MWh.

The smelter consumes about 13% of New Zealand’s whole electrical energy provide, which implies that if it have been to close down, the additional provide would no less than scale back wholesale electrical energy costs within the quick time period, which is the very last thing Meridian needs. Should see.

However it might be in Rio Tinto’s pursuits to strike a deal even when Meridian insists on a considerably increased worth, which might make negotiations show a merry dance.

Analyst Jordan believes it would not make sense for Meridian to return to a power price above $62 per megawatt hour.

Barry Harcourt/Stuff

Analyst Jordan believes it might not make sense for Meridian to return to an influence worth above $62 per megawatt hour.

Negotiations must be primarily based on how a lot Meridian might earn for energy from its Manapouri hydro scheme if it didn’t promote that energy to the smelter, and the way a lot the aluminum smelter might need to pay for energy abroad. .

However determining what these costs is likely to be over the lifetime of the contract is just not a easy matter.

The smelter has extra competitors for energy as nationwide grid operator Transpower accomplished an improve of its transmission community between Clutha and Higher Waitaki forward of schedule in April, permitting extra electrical energy from the decrease South Island to be diverted north.

Meridian can be engaged on a plan that might probably reassign the entire energy it presently consumes to the manufacturing of “inexperienced hydrogen” to be used within the transport trade, though Chief Government Barclay stated it might be ” or or “.

Australian oil and mining giants Woodside Vitality and Fortesk have expressed curiosity within the hydrogen alternative.

Maybe extra importantly, Meridian technology supervisor Man Waipara says the 2 corporations have indicated the worth Meridian would wish to cost for its energy to make the scheme work, and he notes that he Each have an interest.

Globally, low cost gasoline seems to be historic historical past and the price of producing electrical energy from new renewable vegetation is now rising for a change, partially as a result of robust demand for wind generators from Europe within the wake of Russia’s conflict on Ukraine. , probably weakening Rio Tinto’s hand as nicely. .

On high of that, the Electrical energy Authority, the facility trade’s regulator, might probably torpedo any provide offers on the cheaper finish of the spectrum, as final 12 months it estimated that the common family would exceed its electrical energy wants every year. Was paying greater than $200 due to the smelter’s low cost provide deal.

Aluminum prices have fluctuated between less than US$1500/tonne and around $4000/tonne over the past few years, and currently sit at a healthy US$2500/tonne.


Aluminum costs have fluctuated between lower than US$1500/tonne and round $4000/tonne over the previous few years, and presently sit at a wholesome US$2500/tonne.

There can be many different transferring components of the dialog.

For instance, Swanepoel says that within the wake of an overhaul of Transpower’s transmission pricing system, all energy corporations now see “loads of alternatives” to develop new wind farms within the South Island.

Then the federal government’s potential multi-billion greenback funding in a pumped hydro scheme at Lake Onslow in close by Otago has various potential impacts on electrical energy demand and provide.

And it is likely to be unsuitable to imagine that human components couldn’t come into the equation.

Rio Tinto could possibly be left red-faced by any new energy deal which suggests its unique choice to scrap its 2030 energy deal was silly.

However Barclays has reported receiving appreciable suggestions from shareholders who imagine the corporate has gotten too simply and fully slowed down in its negotiations with Gandhale in 2021.

Swanepoel believes this might end in a 10- to 20-year energy deal that may see the worth of electrical energy tied to inflation and maybe the worth of aluminum, and would additionally create extra incentives for sulfur to chop manufacturing when electrical energy was . Briefly provide.

“It is far more honest to either side,” he says.

He means that one mannequin could possibly be a deal Rio Tinto struck final 12 months with Iceland’s nationwide energy firm, Landsveerkjun, to energy its aluminum smelter in Strömsvík on Iceland’s Reykjavík peninsula, which Rio Tinto plans to shut in 2020. had additionally threatened to shut.

As an alternative of a direct worth for energy, Landswirkjun obtained a hidden price linked to the US client worth index and partly to world aluminum costs.

About the author


Leave a Comment